Make your tracks label ready.
Get music feedback on your demo from
the artists behind Kompakt.
Artists
What producers say
- T
Perc provided some very detailed feedback on the technical side (details about mastering/normalization), creative part (where to add an element and why) and also on the industry/label aspect suggesting a few labels, which I didn't know before suiting perfectly my style. I can recommend anyone to get feedback from him, really had the feeling that he took his time to listen carefully and think about valuable feedback!
such on the spot, mindful and detailed feedback on the track, really nudging me towards many important things to look out for mixwise. probably one of the best feedbacks received on echio so far and very quick as well. thanks a lot!!
- G
Great feedback, very detailed. Much appreciated
Hi Ali, thank you for the detailed feedback — really appreciated. I've been following you for six years and I love your sound, so your input carries real weight. I use Echio as a pre-final stage before mastering, and some of your suggestions — especially the low-mid groove — are exactly the outside perspective I needed. Looking forward to sending the next version. Best wishes for the tour!
- P
This was my first experience with Echio and it was incredible. Really thoughtful notes and helpful suggestions. Having this kind of feedback from someone who's music I admire is such a great boost of confidence and a great driver for moving forward with my project. Thank you so much!
Great and very inspiring Feedback!!! Thanks Jen! :)
- X
Honest, useful feedback explained in a way that is understandable and well summarised Thanks, will put it to good use in my next studio nights :)
-
Hi Perc, thank you so much, your feedback has been very valuable and I hope to put it to good use. Also, what you said about more modern production was something I hadn't explicitly mentioned, but you brought it up as an issue, and that's very important to me. I'm really glad I asked you for the deep dive, and I'll definitely do it again. See you soon, Aleks
- J
Jen gave me some great feedback on the mixdown, which gave me good insights about the process and really helped improve the track. Just what I needed!
Very helpful, actionable advice! Great feedback. Thanks!
- J
Your feedback is golden for me .. thanks a lot .. also need more modern lead sound with nice sound design.. im almost there .. tomorrow I ll update my monitors Adam a8h with sonarworks sound id .. I used use dynaudio bm15 but need to change with new generation technology ..will see .. I hope we ll work together one day .. this is dream for me .. vocal sample I buy somewhere else.. Thank you so much Perel I love your music .. my sound is more commercial for you I know .. you are very special artist.. I know we are different genre but your feedback is golden thanks xx jjj
Hi Julienne, Thank you so much! Super helpful, clear, and insightful feedback. I spent a few hours on Saturday working some of the larger points, re-processed, and did a side-by-side on my mixer - very noticeable difference already. The track sounds more like it’s breathing now or has a heartbeat, and it has more impact. I need to dedicate some more time to go through everything in more detail. I’ll send you another version when it’s ready. Thank you again. I really appreciate it.
- m
Thanks so much for taking the time to compare the v1 and v2 - I really appreciate it. Also the Biosphere albums were great recommendations, I hadn't heard of them before. Anyway, thank you again - your feedback (and enthusiasm) was exactly the push I needed.
Thanks! It’s inspiring to hear you enjoyed the track. My biggest takeaway is to nurture authenticity and not compromise its uniqueness, since that’s so rare these days. As for the track, it belongs to an unreleased instrumental album inspired by a time and place in history—when people flocked to Missouri in the late 1800s, believing the natural springs had healing properties. Turns out the healing happened just from the relaxation of spending time by water. I’ll share it with you sometime, Thanks again.
Hi Perc, thanks for your feedback. I’ll check all the advice for upgrading the track. Have a good day, best regards.
Biggups man x
Thank you so much for the super quick and detailed review !! I will work on everything that you said and I hope that I will be able to play the track soon at clubs and parties !
- d
Fantastic feedback and what a super fast response! I've implemented a few of the ideas and tweaks you suggested and the track is sounding better already and I'm much happier with it now. Thanks mate will definitely be asking for feedback again!
Thanks, directions. A quick note on what would catch you attention, transients and your sets, not bandcamp, somewhere, would be nice. Not sure if you read what i sent you on facebook, nevermind, but some information would be great, as i will continue with that work right away. all my best, nico
Extremely thoughtful, earnest, heartfelt, deep dive and encouraging feedback from a skillful listener and great artist. Very much appreciated this video. Thank you Ali!
Thanks so much for the feedback! I really appreciate how thoughtful and detailed it was. It means a lot that you took the time to focus on things that could help me specifically, it really gives me something to work with.
- M
Thanks a ton for the detailed feedback and addressing each point. I will work on those adjustments. If anyone is reading this, I def recommend Perc. Super on point about everything. Cheers
Ivorys feedback was fantasticooo! He helped me a lot and answered my many questions very precisely.
Hi again Perc, thank you for the great feedback on the 2nd version. Your feedback worked very well, and I will use Crack with the maximizer engaged to get a couple more Lufs. I really appreciate that you provided great actionable feedback on a track which is quite different from your sound. So, for those who are reading this, don't let that stop you from asking feedback. Also, thank you for being so quick to provide feedback, I really appreciate it!
-
Dear Perc, Thank you for the thorough review and replying so quickly. Your feedback is very clear and actionable. I will work on the track and send it again for your second feedback. Many thanks! Ricardo (aka The Last Raft)
Thank you so much, you gave me ideas I didn't thought of.
- h
Receiving feedback from Dauwd was such an exciting and rewarding experience. As an artist I deeply admire, hearing his thoughts on my track meant so much to me. I was especially happy to hear him say, “I’m not really sure what to suggest for you, but I’m sure you’ll find something—it’s a really well-made track.” Coming from someone of his calibre, this validation was incredibly reassuring, especially when thinking about sending the track to record labels. His suggestions, like adjusting the mids on the pads and softening the distortion on the drums, were practical and insightful. They helped me see how small refinements can elevate the track even further while maintaining its essence. I also appreciated his encouragement to add more surprises in the arrangement, which has inspired me to think more creatively about keeping the listener engaged. Thank you so much, Dauwd, for your thoughtful and encouraging feedback:)! It’s been a real highlight in my journey as an artist and has left me feeling inspired and confident as I move forward.
Thanks for putting your time in. getting to hear from you really helps my confidence. highly recommend.
this is perfect. thank so much. super helpful and quick as always:)
- G
Thank you so much for your thoughtful advice and sharing some of your expertise. The feedback was comprehensive, good value, covering the bigger picture but also going into lots of detail with really helpful suggestions I wouldn't have otherwise thought about ensuring that my track evolve into something spectacular!
Thanks as always Ivory!
Thanks Chris! Great feedback in terms of actionable items to consider within the track and highlighting what is working well/what parts of the track to embrace.
- s
Thank you for the feedback, Ivory! I'm glad you really liked the track and the little touches you shared really helped. :)
-
Thank you Jennifer, best kind of feedback :)
-
Thanks Ivory great feedback as always!
-
Thanks Jennifer, excellent feedback and look forward to sending you my revised version!
Thank you very much for your feedback, Jen! Without mentioning anything, you have recognized exactly what I am missing in my productions. You've described it well and I can now continue working on it. I'm looking forward to showing you my new version soon.
Thank you very much Jennifer!...very good advice...I will send you a version soon...saludos🙌
Thank you so much, Jennifer, for your response to my difficult question. I really appreciate all your recommendations. Even though I kind of understood most of them myself, it's good to hear them again from such a trusted person as you. It gives me the inspiration to keep working on it as well as try few new options from your list and finally reach my goals.
Hello! Thank you so much for your feedback and your kind words, Jennifer. It gave me some ideas to improve the arrangement and make it a more solid track. Thanks again and sending my best. A.
- a
thanks a lot for you feedback ! a sent you a private message on insta so we can speak a bit more about my music if you want :)
- f
Again, thank you for the feedback. Wil be working on these details.
- f
Constructive feedback. Making the changes and taking everything you pointed out with great appreciation. I hope I can send you more tracks in the future. much love
Thank you very much for the feedback. Very detailed.... I will for sure follow with the suggestions. :)
grazie mille, aprezzo molto il pragmatismo della recensione.
-
Thank you Ivory, really glad you like my track and really appreciate having you as part of my production process to sense check and validate!!
Hey Daniel, yes I really like this version and your suggestions really helped me take it to the next level. I’m happy that it has your seal of approval as ‘ready to play!’ Thank you for taking the time - it means a lot ❤️
Hey Ivory, I am really happy that you liked my track :) . I have made the changes that you have suggested and I sent you more of my demos and promos on Instagram as Predex. You can download the updated version of the track on the demos link. 1st in the row. Thank you so much for the feedback :)
-
Jen, it was really a pleasure to gain insight into my track by you... i love the angle you suggested and i am already hard at work to craft a new version based on your wisdom. Hopefully this new version will gain inclusion in the forthcoming Echio Academy compilation. Much love to you and Echio. You both have something great & vital going here for the next wave of producers/djs coming. Merci! Dash UK ( www.instagram.com/dashukmusic )
-
Thanks for more great honest feedback Ivory!!
- L
Grazie mille non sai quanto mi faccia piacere quello che mi “hai” detto.Ora ti do del tu Per me è un po’ nuova la cosa di mandare musica ad etichette penso sarà a seconda volta che provo quindi per me è un grande traguardo quello che mi hai detto. Se per caso hai qualche consiglio senza farti perdere tempo sul discorso etichette o sul come muoversi sarei contentissimo di riceverlo
I completely understand..thanks a lot🙏🙏
-
Hey Daniel, thank you so much for the feedback. I really appreciate you taking the time to listen and offer your suggestions!
Awesome! Thanks so much for the <3 on my track. I hope it serves you well on the dancefloor. Best, Kurt
-
Αs a beginner I'm trying to find small labels to send music for sure.. As for the specific ones you mentioned in amaeo i had send the track i think one month ago and the other 2 labels i think there is no demo submission..Anyway thanks a lot for the advice and everything!!I appreciate it a lot..
-
Τhe last few months, some of my songs were rejected for the mix, that's why my questions were aimed there. Οf course I'm interested in your opinion and about the rest of the approach to the idea and the arrangement also..
Thanks Ivory! Really positive and constructive feedback/advice. Going to take it all on board and will send you a revised track when ready. Thanks again.
Ciao Ivory! Potrei parlare in italiano se preferisci, ma ho dimenticato di commentare. Grazie per tuo feedback, mi ha piaciuto tantissimo. Ci penso con calma en tutto e for sure, faccio tutti questi cambiamenti, mi sembrano molto interessante! 💙
-
i just make some mixing changes and focus more on the volume of my drums and bass also..I don't know mastering process so i will ask a friend of mine to do that..thank you for your time..
-
Thank Ivory, Legend!!!
-
Thank you Ivory, awesome feedback!
-
Good morning!!nice to meet you too!!I’ll check it after work!!thanks a lot
Thank you for the advice Ivory. I will be releasing the song next month.
Damn, that was FAST! Super happy with the feedback received, Ivory is a true artist and knows how to deliver quality feedback in a way that's both helpful and entertaining. He totally understood what I was trying to do with my track and he gave me the right directions in order to get the the next level. This guy is not just a freaking monster of a producer, but he's also very good with words and knows how to describe music in a very amusing way. Super cool!
- d
Super veloce nel dare il feedback, molto gentile e da molti spunti su cui riflettere e lavorare.
Thank you so much for your time and for your advices. It really makes sense to me and means a lot. I will do an extended version trying to make it a bit longer and adding some more analog feel. These are interesting paths to work on. Your feel is great, your style is an inspiration and always inspired. All the best, see you somewhere, anywhere. Now Î’m gonna go and listen to your video again ;)
- v
Thanks for your informative feedback :)
-
Ivory thank you so so much! This is absolutely great feedback and I truly appreciate it a lot!
-
Thanks for more excellent feedback Ivory!
-
Cheers Ivory, thanks for the prompt and mindful reply, I really appreciate and it really make sense, will do!
Very detailed and useful feedback! We followed your good tips to improve our track. Thank you Ivory !
-
Thanks for the very thorough feedback Ivory, super helpful!
Hallo Sascha, vielen lieben Dank für dein Feedback! Dirk hat super viel Output und ich filter alles durch. Gemeinsam gehen wir dann an die Struktur. Womit ich aber oft hadere ist die Länge des Tracks. Wie kurz darf es sein? Ab wann wirds langweilig? Usw. Wir haben 6 bis 7 Tracks, die alle stilistisch gut zusammen passen. Das Zuende bringen ist ja oft des Künstlers Leid, aber der Gedanke, vielleicht doch von einem Label unterstützt zu werden, zieht. Vielleicht haben wir ja Glück mit unserem Zeugs. Vielen Dank nochmal für deine Empfehlungen. Grüße von Steffi und auch von Dirk
- b
Really helpful feedback, gave specific feedback, both positive things and also constructive suggestions to help me improve.
- b
Thankyou for follow up feedback, it built on feedback from first version with the improvements I made. The detail is really helpful to learn from!
- m
thank you! i really appreciate your detailed evaluation of the demo. i've taken your pinpoint critics into account and changed them. at the same time i changed kick and remake the kick bass separation. im looking forward about your next feedback cheers!
Vielen lieben Dank Sascha, :) Ich war sehr zufrieden mit deinem Videofeedback. Du bist auf alles eingegangen, und hast es auch sehr ausführlich beantwortet. Lg Lucas
Grazie del feedback e delle risposte alle mie domande... Davide
Thank u Ivory for your words, always helpful to get a direct feedback from someone I admire so much.
-
Hi again Gui! Thank you so much for your feedback. I totally understand what you’re advice is. I greatly appreciate it and I will keep working on it. Hope everything keeps going great for you. Cheers!!
-
Grazie del feedback
Really enjoyed the feedback sessions with Ivory! He gave really great feedback as well as helping with the issues in regards to the track. would highly recommend
- b
Obrigado! Really helpful as gave specific actionable feedback including arrangement and mixdown suggestions.
-
Hi Gui! Thank you so much for these kind words and very constructive review of my track. I will make these changes you mentioned, hoping to pull it off in a successful way, hehe. I very much appreciate your insight, and thank you as well for accepting to review the improved version of my demo. Sending my best. Arballium
Sei una bravissima persona. Grazie per le bellissime parole!
-
è un emozione davvero grande sentire queste parole dette da te, grazie mille davvero. Infatti come immaginavo ho fatto una grande lista di etichette alle quali mandare. Ora ho pronte un bel po di cose solo che non hanno ne mix ne master, e anche li ho un po di difficoltà. Riguardo al fatto del "tema centrale" capisco anche io che ho una mancanza ed è quello su cui voglio puntare di più. Sto cercando di fare del mio meglio per sviluppare sempre di più un mio sound. Grazie ancora del feedback molto accurato. Se un giorno potessimo incontraci per fare una breve chiaccherata sarebbe un sogno! P.s. Vengo da Sondrio. Amo come riesci a rendere il dance floor caldo con le tue tracce sono belle da morire.
Dear Gui, many thanks for your feedback. Here my rework after your helpful feedback. I only applied to the mixdown a limitier +9.8 db, so mixdown has some loudness, no mastering done. Brought me lot of help and joy to see your feedback movie <3 - would be great to get your feedback on this version 2 - big hug from Switzerland, Mewa
- D
Thank you, great feedback! I was struggling a bit with the synthlead before the second drop so I agree it could be done better. As soon as I have time I’ll try to implement your suggestions :-) Overall very helpful and inspiring response.
-
I received really great feedback for my demo and will make the corrections needed in order for the track to be perfect. Thank you so much for your time Ivory and will resend another demo as soon as it's complete :)
Thank you so much Ivory!!! I Really enjoy your feedback!! Thanks for your time!
Excellent feedback! Thank you so much for all of your advices and information! Very friendly and willing to help!
-
Hallo lieber Sascha, vielen Dank für dein Feedback! . Wir mögen deine Musik sehr sehr gerne und finden es schon ein wenig verrückt, dass du dir unseren Song angehört hast. Deine Anregungen haben wir als sehr konstruktiv und leicht verständlich aufgenommen. Der Track gehört zu den etwas älteren. Deshalb würden wir dir sehr gerne bald einen unserer Neueren zusenden. Wir freuen uns auf ein weiteres Feedback. Freundliche Grüße von Dirk und Steffi
Big thanks to Ivory for his review. Now I am more confident in my work and know what to pay attention to. I wish you do not to burn out in your creativity!
.jpeg?auto=compress&crop=faces&w=48&h=48&fit=crop)
OPA. Me chamo Beto Noffs. Valeu as dicas da mix. Vou mecher nela. E o Nome também. Vamos considerar esses apontamentos. grande abraco Valeu demais
what can i say? im thankfull and happy to get a detailed input on what can i improve on the track and he made some good points that i wasnt really sure but easy to fix ...
Wow, thank you so much for this and the kind words! Really made my day :)
- h
Thank you for the feedback and I'm really happy you liked the track. I thought the master I received was pushing it too hard, and I feel validated that you felt the same way. I'll try to give it a go myself and send you a follow up. Appreciate your help!
Gui took time to listen to all the tracks I sent and gave a technical feedback as well as arrangement opportunity’s which deeply helps to spot some gaps and improvements for the tracks. Thanks to this I received a valuable point of view and expert advices to help me enhance my work and concentrate on the key elements of the tracks. This is gold ! Thank you Gui and Echio for the opportunity !
Hi Gui, thank you for beautiful feedback. I am open to any collaboration; A:) any label support, including yours. b) any mixing support (with paid of course) c:)any mixing and additional production help d:) and other that I forgot to mention actally this is the limit i can do my best. from that point i should get professional support for mix , and production what we can do together?
Hello Big Boss! Thank you really really much for your details feedbacks! I am feeling extra happy that you give me all that tips and production advices! I did this song in 16:00 hours straight when i was really depressed, when my mind was blocking. Thank you so much for your great vibe, your smile! I loved watch the course on aulart! « Beautiful life » maestro T
How does music feedback work?
- 1 Pick an artist Choose an artist from Kompakt you'd love to send your music to.
- 2 Upload your music Upload your track(s) and tell the artist why you're sending this demo to get the most helpful feedback.
- 3 Get feedback Receive private video feedback from the artist within a few days. You’ll get an automatic refund if an artist doesn’t answer.
Frequently asked questions
Music feedback
-
The artist records a private video breaking down your track — mix, arrangement, sound design, or whatever you ask them to focus on. It lands in your inbox and you can watch it whenever you want, as many times as you like.
-
Early sketches are often the most valuable to get feedback on, before you get lost in too many iterations — but finished tracks work too if you want a second opinion or to get on the artist’s radar.
-
MP3 or WAV, any length. Add a note and links when you upload so the artist knows exactly what to focus on.
-
Most feedback arrives within a few days. If the artist hasn’t responded within 7 days, you’re automatically refunded.
-
You can swap the track as long as the artist hasn’t listened yet. After that you can cancel the request for a refund and start a new one.
-
Yes — you send a private message on the feedback page and the artist will get your comment.