Get Music Feedback from Rrose

I highly appreciate philosophical reflections about the music creation process. This is something that helps me understand this phenomenon more deeply and gives me tools for further critical "evaluation" of the result. As for the track, I totally see what you mean about this airy thing and connecting it deeper with the rhythm, I'll definitely try to do that. Also, this "morphing" approach that you mentioned is always on my mind, but often it's somehow hard to implement while keeping the balance... Something I should train more for sure :) Thank you very much for the comprehensive feedback!

Thankyou so much for the feedback. Lots of good clear tips to help improve the track - will put the new version for some more notes once I've done!

Thanks Rrose! Very-very valuable feedback and further direction, everything you've said is on point. I'll try you next time when it's a new track that is still up to changes.

Hi Seth,Thank you so mutch.You been precious again!

Hi, thanks for the feedback! My idea was to do something very strange, so your feeling was what I was searching for from a listener. I’m constantly battling two sides of my artistic expression: doing club music or doing music “for listening”. I think you immediately spot this duality, and it made me think more deeply about the fact that those two sides probably should be kept separate and not merged as I did in this track (and also in many other). I will probably try to extrapolate two tracks from this one, and follow your advice on giving more attention to the second part with the growling synth. Thank you again for your feedback!

Dear Rrose, You are right, I never felt very interested and always felt like i had to go deeper in sound design but my wish to go deep with sound production comes from the usual definition of a ‘good music producer’. And I thought to be able to master destruction, first I felt I needed to know the standard usage. As you described, I actually figured out my own approach to any kind of sound which is more about founded objects and true randomness. I tried to produce straightforward sounds but I think i like playfulness and destruction. Thank you for your real comments and helpful directions!

Hello, thank you for feedback, it really helps. I knew some lacks and some didn't notice, and i was curious what will you tell, so about digital testpress thing is little joke. You have to approve vinyl testpress for final pressing and now, we have this platform for approving and micro mentoring. So i got new version ready. Cheers

Thanks so much, Rrose, for your great feedback! You've pointed out some areas where I can make improvements that I hadn't even thought about before, and your advice is very helpful in guiding me on what to focus on next. I've started putting some of your suggestions into action, and I can already see an improvement. Now, I feel like I have a much clearer idea of what my next steps should be. I also really appreciate your offer to send over an updated version. I'll get right to work on that so I can send it over soon. Thanks again!

Thank you very mutch for the feedback,your point of view was very constructive and the analysis of the track was brilliant. Now i will do my best to follow your advices!

I love your feedback and I am grateful you accepted to give another one on a new version that I will send you asap ! So many things you said resonated with me and your music influenced me a lot during the process, Im not surprised that the monk chant is close to your heart ! That being said I also have mixed feelings and impostor syndrome using this sample but it blended so well with the rest that I struggled to let go of it haha ! I will definitely try to use the intro and see how it could blend with the rest and maybe torture the sample so it becomes something else or simply just completly take it away ! Its an homage at the end of the day : ) Also if possible of course I would love to send another demo for the Echio Academy contest. Thank you so so much for this beautiful and helpful feedback it means a lot to me. Sending a lot of gratitude your way.

Hello Rrose, Thank you so much for your thoughtful and detailed feedback! Very precise and very actionable - much appreciated! I will use some elements of your feedback. Very good point about having the "crying synth" being slower/more patient! And the delay copies of the kick are anything but subtle :). Thanks again! Ricardo

Thank you a lot for your feedback, I will work on it to improve the track. I hope everything goes well for you. Happy new year ! :)

Thank you for your help! Very honest feedback that I can use to improve the track and my music in general.

Thank you! this is exactly what I needed in terms of feedback. You're right, I have released a lot of music but it's hard to find actual, constructive feedback, and I don't hear my own tracks out in the clubs so I want to make sure I'm going in the right direction and not just losing it on my own in the studio bubble... great, thorough feedback.

Hi Seth! Thank you so much for the feedback. It was illuminating, and really helped to put into context some of the concepts that you covered in the stream. I have not touched this track since submission, so I will be able to jump back in with fresh ears and take your thoughts into account. I will be sure to submit a newer version to you in the coming weeks. See you in the next stream! - Jacob