Get Music Feedback from Polygonia

Thanks Polygonia for the very thoughtful feedback - it gives me some specific ways to go forward as well we some very interesting broader perspective on music making. I really appreciate it!

Thank for the amazingly detailed feedback. Solid actionable advice that I look forward implementing and sharing a more final version.

wow! Thank you so much for the super quick feedback,I wasn't expecting a response til at least after ADE - I very appreciate it very much. Great notes, will tighten up the groove on the first half of the track and tame the bass. I will look into the pads as well! I agree with your general feelings. Tenzia is awesome, so i appreciate that. He is super talented. I guess my closest inspiration would be Loek Frey. I will come back with a new version soon! All the best Morgan

Enormous thanks for such a quick response! Now I definitely won't miss my deadline 😁 Again, the suggestions are so precise and relevant! Appreciate that you express your ideas so clearly!

Thanks so much for your feedback. I'm really glad you enjoyed the track and the improvements I've made in mixing and mastering. I'll definetly look into boosting the high frequencies for this track and my other tracks. It's likely that the issue persists throughout the album. I'll send you the full album soon!! Thanks again:)

Wow, this one was the most helpful and detailed feedback so far :) Thanks so much! It's definitely constructive and helpful. I already started to think about making some changes to the song.

Heya thanks so much this was super helpful, I have implemented your suggestions and am much more pleased with where the track is now. Thanks again : )

Thank you for your thoughtful feedback Hi Polygonia, Thank you so much for taking the time to listen to my track and for giving such detailed and helpful feedback. Thanks for your encouragement and thoughtful critique. It’s helped me see the track from a new perspective and has definitely given me motivation to keep improving. Looking forward to sharing more music in the future! KIYOKO

Thank you for the very supportive, specific and helpful feedback. Great ideas in terms of musical approach as well as clear advice on how to move forward with finding audience. Answered questions that I wasnt even sure how to ask!! I really appreciate it!!!

Precise technical Analysis when i requested philosophy! Recommend!

Thank you very much! Totally agree with your suggestions!

Thank you for the deep review! Very helpful and insightful - as usual! :)

Hey Lindsey, best wishes for you :) Thanks again for listening and taking time. Very happy with the feedback you're giving, detailed, constructive and respectful. I will definitely take this knowledge into my future productions, vary valuable. Cheers, Rico

I'm so sorry I forgot to leave feedback until now! Thank you SO much. The mixing advice was so specific and spot on to help get this to a finished state I'm really happy with. The kind words were also helpful motivation for me to call it "done" and move on. Thanks again for the sincere engagement and feedback.

Lindsey gave constructive feedback on my track, very well explained. Thank you :) Will definitely try to get new feedback on other tracks in the future and also recommend her expertise to others.

Thank you so much for this amazing and precise feedback on both technical and creative aspects ! I really had to know and hear what should be improved in my production and this was on point ! I can now see where to improve on the mixdown, but also on how to make a track more interesting by adding more movement and improve the sound design. Polygonia, you’re the best :)

Great review and suggestions! I feel that my ears are getting more and more trained every time I receive your feedback :) Thanks for sharing your knowledge!

Wow, thank you so much for the feedback! I did not expect that you would appreciate the track so much. To be honest I did not think too much about the kick change, I was just guided by the flow of the track when making arrangement decisions. But it's also good to think about the structure of a track in the context of a DJ set, so thanks for the insight. Your feedback gives me motivation to continue creating more music, and maybe one day you will play my music in one of your sets :)

Thank you so much for your feedback Polygonia, it's super constructive, and you're encouraging me to find my own voice! Motivation is back on :)

Huge thanks for the detailed review! Your suggestions are totally on point! From now on, I'll definitely be braver with low-cutting my kick :)

Thank you so much for your feedback! It was thorough and informative, and I really appreciate it. I’ve heard of loudness meters before, but I’ve never actually used one during mixing. I should definitely start using one to get a better grasp of my track levels. Thanks for pointing that out. I still want the toms to be the focal point of the mix, but you're right—they’re way too loud as they are right now. Also, you were spot-on about the outro. I’ve noticed I tend to get lazy towards the end of my tracks, but you're the first person to mention it. I’ll work on staying focused from start to finish next time. Thanks again for all the valuable insights!

Thank you so much for the precise and detailed feedback, it was super helpful ! I really appreciated the demonstration with the spectrum analyzer aswell.

Amazing. Very productive feedback that resulted in a finished track!!

Thank you so much for the feedback and for addressing my questions so directly! I have a much clearer vision of my future as an artist, and I'm very grateful that you always find the time amidst your touring schedule to give such detailed notes.

This is really stellar feedback, thanks so much, Polygonia. Lots of food for thought here in terms of filling out the arrangement and adding movement in the synths - can’t wait to get going with this! I really appreciate the useful mixing advice too, which I haven’t heard about before. All in all, a refreshing and concise set of tips that has me inspired to dive into the finishing touches. Looking forward to sending you the next version :))) (Sorry for taking a while to get back to you, it’s been a hectic end to the summer...)

Great combination of technical feedback and open-ended ideas that I could implement and still maintain my own creative voice. Thank you!

thank you so much for the feedback and criticism of my track. I think it's a good idea to add some automation to the drums, fade up and down subtly to create a less monotonous feeling. not sure about fills, might be difficult to implement aesthetically, but dynamics (not often, just one or two times) from other elements that are already there might be nice. otherwise I'll just say it's done! many thanks and greetings from Reykjavík, Iceland!

thank you so much for the feedback and your advice. I will do some experiments with different patterns and muting the shaker. adding a layer with more mid freq sounds is a good idea. it will take some time to reach an interesting outcome, but with some patience I'm sure I'll get there! analysing your patterns and see if I can incorporate some ideas into my track would be a good learning experience. this is very helpful, much better than sending a track to someone that just says "sounds good!" haha. thank you and have a great weekend!

Polygonia gave amazing feedback on my track! She addressed all my questions and thoroughly explained any recommended changes with context. She even utilized a spectrum analyzer and commented on how she viewed my track using this tool. Finally, she gave some further ideas for filling out the frequencies and ideas to develop regarding specific elements. Very helpful for my musical journey and I learned so much!!

Hello and thank you so much for all the helpful feedback! I am going to implement your recommendations: more dynamics and ‘surprise’ in the arrangement will definitely improve the song. Thank you!

super super helpful and specific feedback thank you!! I will definitely get on the spectrometer train :))

Thank you for the extensive and constructive feedback! As always, it opens up new perspectives on problematic points that I couldn't see by myself and motivates me to put more work into my production, thanks <3

HI Polygonia, Thanks a lot for the feedback, helped me a lot! Although not sure yet how I can fix it but I'm gonna get some help to do it 8) May I ask what was the name of the program where u showed me the volume of the samples in the track? I use Reason for producing music, and for example my kick has nothing on it, just a distortion, and can't figure out why my tracks are sounding like they are in a box. However I am going to use Ableton with the new tracks and try to get the best out from the ones I made in Reason. Thanks a lot again 8)

Awesome, that was extremely helpful. I will definitely experiment with making the atmosphere louder and toning down the rim shot. My idea for it being so loud was that many elements were washed out, so I wanted it to be in the center for contrast together with the kick and open hat. The idea of having a hierarchy will definitely stick with me in my future productions. Regarding the chords not being so audible after the drop my chain of thought was after having this long ambienty dreamy first part I wanted the drop to just hit with some dry drums to awaken the listener, so the synths are very slowly filtering in, but I might have pushed it a bit too hard. Anyways, your feedback was very, very helpful and helped me comprehend a few things. Have a lovely week

Hey Polygonia, thanks for the feedback. Is really assuring with your comments :) I also felt that i left Pads a bit behind. I need to carefully balance them back with EQ at beginning (without over saturating mix later). Thanks again for support :) Cheers M

Thanks a lot for the feedback, some very specific points. Very respectful and pleasant! Hope to see you play again! :-)

Hello Polygonia, thank you very much for very constructive feedback. It kind of really hit the point that proper Low part of track was not there. Listening on proper speakers i also realised i had put unhealthy amount of compression on kick and bass with long release times that caused weird distorsion and whole low end was quite "kuddelmuddel" .. Following your advice i resynthesized kick+sub and bass did some EQ and layering and i think track sound more (how it sounded in my head) :) Thank again for super clear feedback !

Thank you very much, Polygonia! I really appreciated your responsiveness and the depth with which you analyzed my track. Your comments regarding its structure encourage me to continue to pay particular attention to musical nuances and dynamics in techno music. And your enlightening words about mixing synth sounds with "real-world instruments" exactly capture one of my main musical aspirations. Have a nice Sunday!

Thank you very much for the feedback, Polygonia! I have just fixed the hi-hats. For the other suggestions there are a couple of different approaches which come to my mind. Gonna try them both- it's gonna be a steep learning curve! Thanks heaps! :)

Ayyyyy. Thank you for your feedback again!! Hopefully this final one checks all the boxes! Pushed and pulled on the db's for balance and emphasis points. Appreciate you, so hyped you like the track! Excited to see what happsns >^_^<

Thank you so much for the feedback. It has been really helpful. I missed some important mixing key points in the track and you just opened my eyes on that and other important things to consider in production.

Hello Polygonia! Thank you so much for your honest and thoughtful feedback. Your perspective has helped me consider areas of my production that I overlooked. Your notes are actionable and I will carry them with me for my future projects. I am deeply grateful for your critical listening and insight. I created a new version and have re-uploaded in case you would like to hear. My very best, Luis

Dear Polygonia! This is a super detailed and valuable feedback. It helps me a lot. Thank you very very much! Thanks also for a VST recommendation.

Hey Polygonia, thank you for the good feedback! i had quite some stressy university finishing weeks so it took me a while to get back to you. sorry about that! I will try to change what you suggested in the next days :) Just to let you know: the track got signed and will come out on vinyl with 3 more club oriented tracks of mine. So i am glad to have your feedback to finish the project :-) I will send you the outcome! All the best, Milès

Hi, hope you're feeling better these days. Congratulations on the new EP release as well, it is BANGIN, can't wait to rinse a couple of them out this weekend at this fest in the Mojave desert!! You're consistently stellar, keep it up!!!! I lowered the db on that conga pattern, resampled with transient variation and added some modulation. Generally that pattern is a lot less present in the mix now. Thank you again for the listens, the advice, and the nice words <3 I hope you got a lot of good submissions for this Echio Academy session and that it was an enjoyable experience for you! It has been for me!!

Hey!! Thank you so much for your fast response! I'm glad you approve of my edits and thank you for pointing out the counting issue, I'll try to do something about it! Maybe I'll just record myself counting, haha. Have a nice weekend!

Thank you very much for the detailed feedback, Polygonia! It really changed my perception of the track so it is invaluable to me. I will get on with fixing the mix right away. Thank you!

Thanks so much! Really helpful advice on the mix and the arrangement especially. Very practical and useful so will be actioning these points in this track and future pieces.

I’ll see what I can do about those tonal issues, thank you for the thorough feedback!

Thank you for the feedback, very helpful and understanding! Will make a few changes and let you know the result :)

thank you so much for the detailed feedback! It has helped me with my thought process with this track a lot. I will get in the studio and work on this some more and will send through an updated version asap!

Thank you so much for your incredible feedback! Looking forward to integrating your insights into my general creative process moving forward. Really appreciate the time you took to answer my question and your thoughtful suggestions of how to make my track sing properly =] Will be making the necessary adjustments and sending an updated version soon!

Amazing feedback. Very insightful and precise. All of it is clear enough to work on right away. Thank you 🌵

Thanks a lot for the feedback. As always, your suggestions are to the point, inspiring, and motivating. Also thank you for the possibility of sharing with you an updated version of the demo, I'll give my best :))

Hi Polygonia, thanks a lot for your prompt video. Great feedbacks, I’ll try to re-record the hangdrum, play with the frequencies as you mentioned on other sounds. Really cool, it will definitely help. I wouldn’t have figured it out alone. Nice one!

Cool cool danke dir, ist alles notiert! Ja kick mach ich immer zu laut und da muss ich dann am Ende nach mehrmaligem gegenhören immer zurück rudern.. Ich checks mal aus wie der Rest so wirkt wenn die kick leiser ist weil das mit der snare fühl ich auch, nur bei den fills muss ich mal gucken, ich mags ganz gern dass die so im Hintergrund sind :)

Hey, hey!! Thank you so much for your feedback, again I learned a lot and I’m also really happy that you like the track, that’s a big honour for me and big motivation to keep producing <3 I lowered the bass and posted it on bandcamp so now I’m waiting for the first buyers so I can get myself some jummy plant based meal :)) Lots of love and good luck tomorrow in Berlin!

Your feedback was incredibly valuable to me. You gave me a lot of practical insights about how to bring my track to the next level, and I was actually surprised by how detailed your feedback was, both in analyzing what my track was lacking and in pointing out possible ways to tackle those issues. I thank you very much about this and I'm very grateful that you have shared these advices with me.

Round two with Polygonia, and the feedback is a game-changer for my music journey! Having different perspectives has been pure gold. 🎶 The insights are spot-on, highlighting areas I might have missed. The team's expertise shines through, making each round an enlightening experience. Can't praise them enough! Ready and eager for the next round of musical gems. 🚀✨

Thank you for this feedback! It was very helpful. I submitted a track that was very near completion and I was just looking for very specific nit-picky feedback and Polygonia really delivered insightful and constructive feedback and specific suggestions to help my track really shine that much more. It was great to have my track heard by experienced, seasoned ears for electronic music.

Thank you so much for the feedback! It's truly very comprehensive, covering aspects I hadn't even thought of or knew about. It's also great to have a fresh set of professional ears, especially for new artists like me. I'm loving the service, and I wholeheartedly recommend it. I will definitely be sending more in the future.

Great, informative and professional feedback. Answered all my questions with honest and detailed explanations, while also including examples and suggestions where I could further resolve any issues in my track! Would definitely recommend Polygonia to anyone else seeking feedback :)

Heyy, thank you so much for your detailed feedback, it's exactly what I was hoping for - it reveals things I didn't notice and gives me so much motivation to do the next track which will be better in the aspects you're pointing out. I'm honored to be your first Echio case and also your feedback video coming on the day of your new EP release feels special and inspiring :)) Love it!!