Many thanks for your detailed feedback! It's very useful and actionable.
I will definitely pay more attention to the track structure and play more with silence.
P.S. Instrument-wise, it's mostly granular synthesis from field recordings.
Very happy and excited. Thank you so much for the feedback, which was also very quick, arriving just a day after I sent the track. Very grateful indeed. I will take your tips to heart 🙏
Useful feedback and advice, even though it could have been a little bit more detailed. Thank you!
How does music feedback work?
1Pick an artistChoose an artist from Ilian Tape you'd love to send your music to.
2Upload your musicUpload your track(s) and tell the artist why you're sending this demo to get the most helpful feedback.
3Get feedbackReceive private video feedback from the artist within a few days. You’ll get an automatic refund if an artist doesn’t answer.
Frequently asked questions
Music feedback
The artist records a private video breaking down your track — mix, arrangement, sound design, or whatever you ask them to focus on. It lands in your inbox and you can watch it whenever you want, as many times as you like.
Early sketches are often the most valuable to get feedback on, before you get lost in too many iterations — but finished tracks work too if you want a second opinion or to get on the artist’s radar.
MP3 or WAV, any length. Add a note and links when you upload so the artist knows exactly what to focus on.
Most feedback arrives within a few days. If the artist hasn’t responded within 7 days, you’re automatically refunded.
You can swap the track as long as the artist hasn’t listened yet. After that you can cancel the request for a refund and start a new one.
Yes — you send a private message on the feedback page and the artist will get your comment.
.jpeg?auto=compress&crop=faces&w=640&h=640&fm=webp&fit=crop)
