Get Music Feedback from James Harcourt

Good honest actionable feedback, some of which I can use to bring my track closer to the finish line. Thank you.

Insightful actionable feedback, thank you.

James feedback and expertise has been invaluable to us in navigating the underground electronic music industry as new artists. He consistently provides the detailed and honest feedback and suggestions on our track mixdowns to gain that extra ~10% bump in the quality and fine details in our tracks to help us gain the attention of labels and other DJs/producers. His suggestions for who we should reach out to with our demos has been consistently on the nose, and we credit the ongoing relationships we've built over the last two years with small house/techno labels in large part to him. The comprehensiveness and promptness of his video responses to music feedback requests is top-tier, and in our opinion, unparalleled on Echio.

Thanks to James feedback, I was able to develop the track such that it was signed by Electronic Groove records, and became part of an EP collaboration with Maze 28, and Ricky Ryan. Thank you James

49 miles ended up getting signed by Keep Thinking Music, and went on to be one of my best selling tracks, including support from the likes of John Digweed, in which the track was featured on his transitions show. Thanks James

Good feedback, just what I was looking for to drive my track to be completed! Appreciate the thoughts.

It was very helpful, and I really appreciated the honesty and objectivity

Perfect - thanks James. Yeah, look forward to receiving that when you get chance and we'll get into one of the last 3 as a starting point. Hope you get some chance to unwind, too!

Hey James, Thank you for taking the time to review my track. Really appreciate your valuable insight and your feedback! Based on your feedback I believe I'll be working on a separate track to complement it and possibly combine it with a track I already have. To answer your question, I live in Doha, Qatar where most of the music being played is top10 afro house charts and pop remixes. But will be testing it out when the time is right for sure! Once I have Chaka boom mastered, ill send it to you through instagram (@laymoon.official) Thanks again!

Spot on, as always - thanks JH!

Sterling feedback and constructive comments as always. Don't even run music by anyone else anymore as I trust JH judgement calls and value his input.

Thanks James!

Yeah, I think that's all fair comment and very useful. Thanks as always, James!

Great, thanks, James. Useful to get that final 5% out of the track. Cheers!

That's absolutely stellar - thanks James. Above and beyond expectation - much appreciated! btw - yeah it's a stick - bit brittle perhaps - will drop it. Thanks again!

Hey James - massively helpful as always on musical and other fronts. Be back to you with a new version when I address those points! Best, Louis

Always relevant and super accurate advices, thanks again!

Thanks so much for this very positive feedback! I will work on those adjustments, they feel quite accurate and hope they can bring the general result up to a really great track. I already did a review in the past with James and that quite opened my eyes on many levels, so thanks for that. I knew you would bring another constructive and useful feedback. Thanks James!

Your feedback is really helpful! I like how you justified every aspect of it! Thank you!

Thanks, James. Top calibre feedback as always!

James, thank you so much for the amazing feedback and support. I really appreciate the time you took to listen and share your thoughts. I'm thrilled with the feedback and can't wait to bring you another track soon!

James' feedback has been so immensely helpful -- his attention to the details on the sound design of the tracks is incredibly useful in catching ways to take a track to the place where I can be proud of it. <3

Thanks again for the feedback, really appreciated!!! That acapella is from underground resistance - transitions, classic detroit track.. was a hard acapella to work with since its pretty rough and already had all the delays added in from the original. Cheers, Curtis

Amazing Feedback James, Thank you so much!!! I took all of your advice and the track sounds a million times better and is definitely Club ready now and I'm quite happy with it!!

James - rest assured you've more than earned your crust as always. So grateful for your help with the evolution of this track. You always hone in on exactly what is required. I'm delighted with the end result. Thanks so much. Louis

Brilliant, thanks James. Yeah, I had a play using portal and some fabfilter stuff but didn't quite land. I'm going to rest it as suggested while I'm away and come back fresh. Thanks again and speak soon. Louis

Thanks, James - appreciate the 'journey' we've been on somewhat together for this one. Will park it until Sunday - honest, and then have a final look at that main break. Thanks again! Louis

As always, James provided stellar feedback that gave me honest and constructive advice on finishing the track.

Hi James! It was great to get 'live' feedback, so thanks very much. It appears I've confused you - my name IS Louis, but for some reason at the beginning/end of my last 3 feedbacks you've called me Boris. So, hence I said it's me 'Boris' - anyway, yes, I'm Louis. OK, so the feedback as always has been v useful. I'm going to work on that second break, nix the 3rd and try that additional interest element around 3:50. I'll let you know how it goes! Best, Louis

Hi James, Thanks as always for that - always prefer truth bombs to platitudes. Lots to take away - mainly to get a bit more into the weeds with my sound design. In terms of what I call 'bigger labels' - yes definitely guys like Siamese, Diynamic, Renaissance, Sprout, etc. I think I'll keep running with this track as I think it has something to it, but will rip out the sound design and start from a solid idea and build out again. Best, Louis (or Boris as you call me for some reason? :) )

Hey James! Thanks so much for the straight up feedback..always really appreciate that from you. I'll make some tweaks in line with your suggestions and maybe send back to you for when you get home. Safe trip! Louis (or Boris as some call me 🤣)

Very constructive with pure honnesty and detailed feedback, which is what I need. Thanks

We can't thank you enough James for taking the time to review our track! You really went above and beyond what we expected re: review/feedback. We felt our track was in a good place sonically, and hearing this from you was a massive boost for our confidence. But beyond that we really appreciate the specific details for how we could keep improving our productions. Experimenting with more unconventional transitions and drum sounds is something we definitely agree with and we will be experimenting with in our upcoming tracks. Re: the length of the track, we agree its definitely on the longer side, it wasn't our intention, but it just felt right as we were building out the arrangement - but we're very open to making an edit or shorter version if needed to get more attention from prospective labels. Thank you again, and we'll definitely be reaching back for feedback on our next productions! Excited for what the future holds :)

Hi James Wow! I don't expected this long and constructive feedback! Thanks for this and your good advices, of course. I can say, that I know what you mean and there was nothing in the video that I can't understand. In the end I am very happy about the feedback and every token was a good investment. P.S. My family had a Labrador a year ago, dogs are great. :-D Greetings Christopher

Thank you for the quick response and the great feedback. You gave some in depth honest advice which hopefully I can use to make this a better, more professional sounding track. I appreciate you spending time to help others with feedback.

Good detailed feedback. James definitely knows his stuff when it comes to production!!

Hi James, I very much appreciate your quick response and comments on my track. I like your review. You have really pointed out what changes could be made to take it to the next level. Now I can work on a new version more objectively. Thanks for your time and your help.

First off I would like to thank James on the really in depth and honest review of my track, couldn't of asked for a better feedback video. It was very informitave and thoughtful. I went over all the advice James had for me to try and make a more professional sounding song and in no time my track was sounding way better. Really Appreciate James taking the time to do these feedback vids :)

Hey James, That's great to hear - thank you! Really appreciate the words of wisdom as always. Best, Louis

More really dialed-in feedback that has helped me take the track up a notch. Much appreciated as always!

Thanks James.

Great to get an honest take on this one. I feel it has potential but agree it's not there yet. Much appreciated!

More pertinent advice. Definitely agree transitions are something I need to spend more time on - tend to get an idea down quickly but then fade away from the details. Thanks again for your valued feedback.

Thanks so much for the insightful feedback. Just what I needed to rethink and re-approach the tracks with a clear direction. I never ask for feedback just to receive platitudes, so the constructive criticism was welcome! Thanks again!

Hi James Appreciate the response in a flash! Thank you for that. Like you said, saying “yeah, it’s great” is easy but not the point. Constructive criticism I was looking for and thank you for that. Big boost to hear that 20hours project is at release level. Shows the improvement that comes when you put in the work. I’ve been feeling confident with the low end, rhythm and mix lately so your comments give me more confidence I’m on the right path with what I’ve been doing so far. Synthesise is something i have just started breaking through and coming up with processing tricks to alter preset sounds. Still experimenting and trying to educate myself on that. Feels like I need to do a bit more research on plug ins too. Not that they will make me creative but having something new to play with sometimes creates moments that spark projects. Also the idea with a group of sounds to alternate and edit is something that I’ll definitely implement. Great, overall I’m very happy with it all!!! Thank you again for your time James. I’ll send you a new demo at some point and I appreciate the offer for a free preview of Electrified🖤✊🏿 Gova

Thanks James. Really positive and helpful feedback. I have implemented the changes you mentioned and they work really well. Especially the kick roll.... keeping it up into the break. I will run it on my CDJs over the weekend and mix with some other proven tracks (including yours) and see how it fairs. Thanks again. Will be sending more tracks over to you as I get to them!! Appreciate all your help and contact information. Cheers. Have a great weekend!!!

James’s feedback was invaluable. Detail given around sound design, arrangement, and mix. I was also advised on labels and who may be interested in this. Guidance on how I might present the track in the form of an EP was a great suggestion. I’ve already implemented his suggestions. I will be using James for all my future projects (if he has the time!). Thanks James. Have also recommended you and this service to fellow producers.